Post 1 by Stardom Stable
Edited Permalink, post#124 bought, 15 shot or retired, 9 that will struggle to place in a $5 claimer and self selected SR ban now in place
SR isn't worth the money
just my thoughts
SR isn't worth the money
just my thoughts
My Words each Season, some Stables have a Golden Hand for the SR, i didn´t count to them tooStardom Stable wrote view post
24 bought, 15 shot or retired, 9 that will struggle to place in a $5 claimer and self selected SR ban now in place
SR isn't worth the money
just my thoughts
dont understand what you mean when you say ratio of poor horses is way out of line? i retired or pastured horses that where farming 3.35 at 2m with full adds on that will never ever make a racer regardless how much they improve farm to track, out of the 24 the likelyhood is i'm only going to end up keeping and racing 4 of them so basically 1 in 6 horses ive bought from the SR this season will see the track and even they might not ever earn anything, i'm confident that every HB yearling i have in my stable now will earn money and i reckon ive kept 70%+ of the breeds ive done which is a hell of a lot better (and cheaper).Black Cat Racing wrote view post
Why shoot or retire a yearling when you do not know the level,of maturity? Whilst I buy few from the SR the ratio of poor horses is way out of line with my experience.
Jim
BCR
I hhave never seen any hhorse improve oover ffiffteen seconds,, whhich is whhat woould be needed for these to be raceable.Black Cat Racing wrote view post
This raises an interesting observation concerning the difference in mindset required in this game and another we have all been involved with. A yearling doing 3.35 at the farm over 2 miles is unlikely to be a top performer but could it improveand operate profitability? That is the important decision that has to be made in this game in assessing the viability of keeping that horse to allow it to mature and improve. The time of 3.35 currently equates to a one Star in training at the farm which is not great but could this horse improve and be profitable on the track - yes I believe it could . I currently have a number of yearlings performing at a similar level in my stable, although home bred. They will be retained until the maturity level can be factored in.
There is a lesson in mindset required in this game here and that is never underestimate the potential for horses to improve.
Jim
BCR
sales ring horses need to be able to compete against homebreds in both ability and maturiity iff players are to be expected to buy them.Sport of Kings wrote view post
Frustration noted but what could be done to help alleviate it?
The amount of top horses being bred far out ways the amount of top horses being brought from the SR yet it's costing more per horse from the SR, why is it that the majority of HB start off on way lower maturity than the majority of SR, is it by design? Should the 2 sets of horses be more closely matched in that aspect?Sport of Kings wrote view post
Frustration noted but what could be done to help alleviate it?
With the new 3 month season starting in January you should see Sales Ring horses being a lot more competitiveStardom Stable wrote view post
The amount of top horses being bred far out ways the amount of top horses being brought from the SR yet it's costing more per horse from the SR, why is it that the majority of HB start off on way lower maturity than the majority of SR, is it by design? Should the 2 sets of horses be more closely matched in that aspect?Sport of Kings wrote view post
Frustration noted but what could be done to help alleviate it?
maybe but i wouldn't put money on it, even now after just 2 months of the season most of my homebreds have overtaken nearly all my SR in racing, and thats with a reletively small stable, you bigger stables will have top homebreds competetive a lot earlier than meNemesis Stud wrote view post
With the new 3 month season starting in January you should see Sales Ring horses being a lot more competitiveStardom Stable wrote view post
The amount of top horses being bred far out ways the amount of top horses being brought from the SR yet it's costing more per horse from the SR, why is it that the majority of HB start off on way lower maturity than the majority of SR, is it by design? Should the 2 sets of horses be more closely matched in that aspect?Earlier quote from Sport of Kings
Sport of Kings wrote view post
Frustration noted but what could be done to help alleviate it?
Dont see how that will make any difference Nem!?If it is the case then that makes the horses he got even worse!!lolNemesis Stud wrote view post
With the new 3 month season starting in January you should see Sales Ring horses being a lot more competitiveStardom Stable wrote view post
The amount of top horses being bred far out ways the amount of top horses being brought from the SR yet it's costing more per horse from the SR, why is it that the majority of HB start off on way lower maturity than the majority of SR, is it by design? Should the 2 sets of horses be more closely matched in that aspect?Earlier quote from Sport of Kings
Sport of Kings wrote view post
Frustration noted but what could be done to help alleviate it?
Just a point here, rigght back at the beginning Brian stated that the sales ring iis designed to worrk withh thhe breeding program. Soo top level was meant too be very similar and the sales ring was meant to ffiill gaps lefft by breeding. ie we breed loads of sprinters and not manyy stayers, so the sales ring would adjust to throw more stayers.MJ Stables wrote view post
I really can't complain I have done OK from the sales ring. But in answer to the question earlier is that I agree very few sr horses make it to champs level but many do make a nice profit. The answer I would give is no I do not think that sr should be on a pat with homebreds. Price is irrelevant it has always been this way. But until we know the ratio of sr bought against homebreds we will not know if the % is better. There are many trainers on here that love the sr and we all learn something new all the time and this season I have learned that farm times and pw don't really mean a lot until the horse hits the track
Log in to join the conversation.