Sport of Kings wrote view post
The way the grouping works is easy enough to sort out and I there is little argument for deviating from what exists. The issue is that the ratings and weights are all assigned by a handicapper (human). We are trying to automate a very human process and come up with a system. As I said from the start, the full implementation of this isn't a simple task.
Let me try to identify the points of issue:
1)How we can assign that initial rating
1a) (This may answer the first question - requiring a previous start) What age should these be for? Seniors Only?
2) How large of jumps in the ratings horses should be able to make on the back of a single race.
3) Should we include non handicapped races in the calculations for rating (this seems to be a yes as there is seemingly no way around it)
Other items that have gone unsaid but are going to be true:
1) The purse size will increase as the rating range does (0-75 will have the smaller purses)
2) There will be inevitable competition to have the highest rated horse in the division / overall which is great.
1) you should know how the game identifies horses already as being good or not so good also the betting seems to wokout whos top rated etc if these measures cant be deployed then use 3 maidens to work it out is up to owners to use there nous in these maidens to get a rating .
In real racing a horse may run 3 maidens over the wrong distance at 2yr to then race over the right distance at 3 yr to be one step ahead of the handicapper and thus able to pick off two wins before the handicapper has a grip on the horse .
but i do think your system should be identifying chally horses from the off and giving them a group status and within that they can move up and down amongst the group races to group 3-1 and the odd hanndicap horse will break through to group races.
1) a definately not imo
2) it depends on how hars a win penalty is usually a 2lb pen in quals is deemed near pointless once over the 4lb mark vitually unwinnable so your the best judge of that but i would suggest 3lb for the win 2lb for a place 1lb for the next 3 then minus 1 for those upto 11 and for the last 4 minus 2lbs but to be honest it depends on how weight really effects horses and as yet i dont know how much each lb effects each horse time wise on here.
3 ) youve answered