⚖ SPORT OF KINGSTRACK TIME

Rating System

Pinned114 replies · 1,057 views

  1. Post 1 by SOK Admin

    Permalink, post#1
    We are creating this thread for feedback on the rating system as we go.

    Let's begin by asking should ratings be impacted by races outside of the handicap system? It seems unwise to allow a horse to do well in a championship race and not move up in the ratings. The reason would be that they would have 4 or 5 races in the bottom group for handicaps before being promoted (if 4 points is the maximum movement for each race result). By the same token, a poor performance outside of the handicap system should make a horse regress in rating as well. Or not?


  2. Post 2 by Chaos Rules

    Permalink, post#2
    My first instinct would be to say yes all races with the possible exception of claimers should count towards a horses rating. My main line of reasoning being do we want a handful of stables with a handful of top horses dominating qualifiers, finals and what look sure to be lucrative handicaps as well? I feel handicaps should primarily be the province of the horses that range between raceable to just below championship class. However there does need to be enough horses available for the championship and part of the skill of the game may be in balancing a top horses wins in handicaps so it still has a chance in championship races. Interesting times ahead.
  3. Post 3 by Brisflyers

    Permalink, post#3
    tbh i have no idea how the rating system works lol maybe you could stick a full field example up of how the finishing order affects ratings cos i for 1 havent got a clue
  4. Post 4 by SOK Admin

    Edited Permalink, post#4

    Chaos Rules wrote view post

    My first instinct would be to say yes all races with the possible exception of claimers should count towards a horses rating. My main line of reasoning being do we want a handful of stables with a handful of top horses dominating qualifiers, finals and what look sure to be lucrative handicaps as well? I feel handicaps should primarily be the province of the horses that range between raceable to just below championship class. However there does need to be enough horses available for the championship and part of the skill of the game may be in balancing a top horses wins in handicaps so it still has a chance in championship races. Interesting times ahead.
    It is worth noting that wins from handicaps are not counted in the championship series. This was done partly in an effort to give those horses more opportunities to run but we want it to be against the correct caliber of competition.

    Bris,
    The rating system itself is fairly detailed but not all the complicated.

    The current max movement is 4 points up or 4 points down. The maximum movement is adjusted based on the quality of the race (a better race has less movement down while a poor race has less movement up).
    • Winner will receive the maximum increase in rating.
    • The others in the top 25% will receive the max increase - 1
    • The next 25% (25-50%) will receive the max increase - 2 (or 0 whichever is greater)
    • The third 25% (50-75%) will receive the max DECREASE - 1
    • The bottom 25% will receive the maximum DECREASE
    I don't see why this couldn't accumulate for all races the horse runs and there probably needs to be a bigger upside jump for those in the elite races.
  5. Post 5 by True Blue Stable

    Permalink, post#5
    Whilst I think that all races should count for a Rating system, a horse should not get a rating until it has ran a few times. Any horse without a rating should be Top Weight in races it participates in.
  6. Post 6 by SOK Admin

    Permalink, post#6

    True Blue Stables wrote view post

    Whilst I think that all races should count for a Rating system, a horse should not get a rating until it has ran a few times. Any horse without a rating should be Top Weight in races it participates in.
    I think to this point we will not be offering handicap races for the younger horses. It would be possible to set an initial rating based on the speed ratings the horse puts up but that offers itself to manipulation.
  7. Post 7 by Green Field Stud

    Permalink, post#7

    Sport of Kings wrote view post

    True Blue Stables wrote view post

    Whilst I think that all races should count for a Rating system, a horse should not get a rating until it has ran a few times. Any horse without a rating should be Top Weight in races it participates in.
    I think to this point we will not be offering handicap races for the younger horses. It would be possible to set an initial rating based on the speed ratings the horse puts up but that offers itself to manipulation.
    3 maidens like the real world should give a horse a handicap, it would be sad to get handicaps not as good as they could be by trying to tie them around fitting a hole for horses who have become too overweight for chally.
    but a separate handicap class for the top horses may be a soloution here . but its worth bearing in mind that champs rarely run handicaps and just the odd one progresses from handicaps to group races which should happen on here too as horses grow.
    you should make group races for the champ horses based on handicaps the same but group 1 group 2 and group 3 race in the same races each group fitting in varying class of champs same as handicaps but graded by being group 1 2 or 3. these races could be for champ class horses throughout there career only those supped. no need for champ class horses to interfere with handicaps, any horses who are rated in the group class not wanted to be nommed by owners could be sold traded through privates shot or stuck in claims.
  8. Post 8 by Green Field Stud

    Edited Permalink, post#8

    Sport of Kings wrote view post

    Chaos Rules wrote view post

    My first instinct would be to say yes all races with the possible exception of claimers should count towards a horses rating. My main line of reasoning being do we want a handful of stables with a handful of top horses dominating qualifiers, finals and what look sure to be lucrative handicaps as well? I feel handicaps should primarily be the province of the horses that range between raceable to just below championship class. However there does need to be enough horses available for the championship and part of the skill of the game may be in balancing a top horses wins in handicaps so it still has a chance in championship races. Interesting times ahead.
    It is worth noting that wins from handicaps are not counted in the championship series. This was done partly in an effort to give those horses more opportunities to run but we want it to be against the correct caliber of competition.

    Bris,
    The rating system itself is fairly detailed but not all the complicated.

    The current max movement is 4 points up or 4 points down. The maximum movement is adjusted based on the quality of the race (a better race has less movement down while a poor race has less movement up).
    • Winner will receive the maximum increase in rating.
    • The others in the top 25% will receive the max increase - 1
    • The next 25% (25-50%) will receive the max increase - 2 (or 0 whichever is greater)
    • The third 25% (50-75%) will receive the max DECREASE - 1
    • The bottom 25% will receive the maximum DECREASE
    I don't see why this couldn't accumulate for all races the horse runs and there probably needs to be a bigger upside jump for those in the elite races.
    the + and - look wrong in your illustration
    no races other than handicaps should count towards handicap ratings unless its needed if the game can only cope with doing ratings by rating each race. reason being the cheapest nom races will be full of horses loosing weight for handicap races unless you can get all horses to race off 100% in every race which i think sould happen anyway a vet would stop horses racing so unfit and it should be same on here.
    There has to be more skill than just running unfit when not trying to win, even in quals if your trying not to win it should be by dropping some tack, i personaly would only allow one piece of tack to be removed or added each race, otherwise i would call the stewards in :).this would add more skill and make certain horses better at handicapping than others not all relating to how good they are respectively on time.
  9. Post 9 by Micks Heroes

    Edited Permalink, post#9
    I'm wondering if handicap racing and championship racing should be kept separate from each other.

    My main reasoning is that players could plunder a number of handicap races with an unraced championship type horse before the horse then moves on to qualifiers.

    You say that handicap races might not be offered to younger horses. What age did you have in mind for this because I have a number of unraced 3yo horses that would be ideal to exploit this potential loophole?

    Maybe the only way to stop this happening would be if handicap wins did impact on championship races. Even if this was implemented, an unraced 3yo could still plunder two handicap races before weight penalties were incurred for championship races. Taking it to extremes, if the horse was unraced until it became 4yo it would then be able to clock up 5 handicap wins before being penalised with extra weight!

    Think you definitely need a ruling whereby unraced horses are ineligible for handicaps.
  10. Post 10 by Green Field Stud

    Permalink, post#10

    Sport of Kings wrote view post

    True Blue Stables wrote view post

    Whilst I think that all races should count for a Rating system, a horse should not get a rating until it has ran a few times. Any horse without a rating should be Top Weight in races it participates in.
    I think to this point we will not be offering handicap races for the younger horses. It would be possible to set an initial rating based on the speed ratings the horse puts up but that offers itself to manipulation.
    some form of manipulation by players with there horse will be vital for handicaps just as the real world trainers and owners want to get there horses as well handicapped as possible before trying for the win
  11. Post 11 by Top barn

    Permalink, post#11

    Green Field Stud wrote view post

    Sport of Kings wrote view post

    Earlier quote from True Blue Stables

    True Blue Stables wrote view post

    Whilst I think that all races should count for a Rating system, a horse should not get a rating until it has ran a few times. Any horse without a rating should be Top Weight in races it participates in.
    I think to this point we will not be offering handicap races for the younger horses. It would be possible to set an initial rating based on the speed ratings the horse puts up but that offers itself to manipulation.
    some form of manipulation by players with there horse will be vital for handicaps just as the real world trainers and owners want to get there horses as well handicapped as possible before trying for the win
    All horses, no matter what age,start racing in a maiden race,unless deemed to be top class by either its breeding or training performance.After its maiden race it will be assessed and given a rating.This rating will determine the lowest class of race it can enter ie if say the horse wins a maiden and is allocated a rating of say 70 it could enter a 0-70 handicap but would carry top weight
  12. Post 12 by Top barn

    Permalink, post#12
    you would not be able to race a horse rated 100 in a 0-75 handicap therfore this system would give players more idea of the competition they may be facing.e.g a 3 horse race of 0-75 with 2 winners in the race carrying 112lbs and horse beaten say 8lengths by one of these in its last race then this horse would recieve 8lbs.In theory the result between the 2 horses inquestion should be a dead heat but then you have to take other factors like going jockey, fitness, running style equipment etc
  13. Post 13 by SOK Admin

    Edited Permalink, post#13
    The way the grouping works is easy enough to sort out and I there is little argument for deviating from what exists. The issue is that the ratings and weights are all assigned by a handicapper (human). We are trying to automate a very human process and come up with a system. As I said from the start, the full implementation of this isn't a simple task.


    Let me try to identify the points of issue:
    1)How we can assign that initial rating
    1a) (This may answer the first question - requiring a previous start) What age should these be for? Seniors Only?
    2) How large of jumps in the ratings horses should be able to make on the back of a single race.
    3) Should we include non handicapped races in the calculations for rating (this seems to be a yes as there is seemingly no way around it)

    Other items that have gone unsaid but are going to be true:
    1) The purse size will increase as the rating range does (0-75 will have the smaller purses)
    2) There will be inevitable competition to have the highest rated horse in the division / overall which is great.
  14. Post 14 by Brisflyers

    Edited Permalink, post#14
    handicaps are just glorified allowances would it not have been easier just to card a few hundred allowance races into the season ? ya could have easily adjusted the allowances to say winner goes up 4lbs losers go down 4lbs min weight 106 lbs max weight 140 lbs

    i have no doubt these handicaps if you go ahead will thrive ya will deffo need to up the min entry though from 5 to maybe 12 ide say but getting the ratings sorted is very important or the senior monsters and theres quite a few in g1 and g3 will just rape these races simple as as monsters weighted out of champs have nowhere else to go as all the added stakes races no longer exist ye they will have the overnighters for g1 to pillage but imsure they will pillage easy pickens from these handis aswell ,so how ya rate a horse b4 it enters a handi is very important
  15. Post 15 by Chaos Rules

    Permalink, post#15
    I would just add that the rules governing these handicaps will have to be very clear and precise as to what can be done and what cannot because touching on GFS point everyone will want to make their own horse the best handicapped and there are many ways to go about this. A horse could run with wrong tack and i do not see how this could be governed as i often run horses with wrong tack through sheer ignorance and the site cannot tell a trainer that their horse is wrongly tacked. And how about if a horse is public worked and runs at low fitness? Will that be fair or legal? Will there be some mechanism in place to ensure horses are rejected from the race if not fully fit? Here's an even trickier one; suppose a sprinter runs in a stayer or vice-versa in an attempt to manipulate the handicap? Will that be acceptable as it seems pretty much impossible to legislate against?
  16. Post 16 by Green As Grass

    Edited Permalink, post#16
    Another thing to add..in real racing the governing body has no idea how good /bad a horse is ,im sure the governing bodies on here do....so why not start from date of birth getting horses rated .....on the probability of there ability...just a thought...if they are shit rate them as shit...(we will know anyway)lol,if good then rate them against best horse on site at each distance...not easy as that i know but surely they can get some sort of rating..then at least we all know where to run it ...and will be plenty of races to get it in if handicaps are an option too...and also a chally will be easier to spot to add a few more to chally races...gets people racing instead of peeing about training and waiting in hope of improvement too...
  17. Post 17 by Green Field Stud

    Permalink, post#17

    Sport of Kings wrote view post

    The way the grouping works is easy enough to sort out and I there is little argument for deviating from what exists. The issue is that the ratings and weights are all assigned by a handicapper (human). We are trying to automate a very human process and come up with a system. As I said from the start, the full implementation of this isn't a simple task.


    Let me try to identify the points of issue:
    1)How we can assign that initial rating
    1a) (This may answer the first question - requiring a previous start) What age should these be for? Seniors Only?
    2) How large of jumps in the ratings horses should be able to make on the back of a single race.
    3) Should we include non handicapped races in the calculations for rating (this seems to be a yes as there is seemingly no way around it)

    Other items that have gone unsaid but are going to be true:
    1) The purse size will increase as the rating range does (0-75 will have the smaller purses)
    2) There will be inevitable competition to have the highest rated horse in the division / overall which is great.
    1) you should know how the game identifies horses already as being good or not so good also the betting seems to wokout whos top rated etc if these measures cant be deployed then use 3 maidens to work it out is up to owners to use there nous in these maidens to get a rating .
    In real racing a horse may run 3 maidens over the wrong distance at 2yr to then race over the right distance at 3 yr to be one step ahead of the handicapper and thus able to pick off two wins before the handicapper has a grip on the horse .
    but i do think your system should be identifying chally horses from the off and giving them a group status and within that they can move up and down amongst the group races to group 3-1 and the odd hanndicap horse will break through to group races.
    1) a definately not imo
    2) it depends on how hars a win penalty is usually a 2lb pen in quals is deemed near pointless once over the 4lb mark vitually unwinnable so your the best judge of that but i would suggest 3lb for the win 2lb for a place 1lb for the next 3 then minus 1 for those upto 11 and for the last 4 minus 2lbs but to be honest it depends on how weight really effects horses and as yet i dont know how much each lb effects each horse time wise on here.
    3 ) youve answered
  18. Post 18 by Green Field Stud

    Permalink, post#18

    Top barn wrote view post

    Green Field Stud wrote view post

    Earlier quote from Sport of Kings

    Sport of Kings wrote view post

    Earlier quote from True Blue Stables

    True Blue Stables wrote view post

    Whilst I think that all races should count for a Rating system, a horse should not get a rating until it has ran a few times. Any horse without a rating should be Top Weight in races it participates in.
    I think to this point we will not be offering handicap races for the younger horses. It would be possible to set an initial rating based on the speed ratings the horse puts up but that offers itself to manipulation.
    some form of manipulation by players with there horse will be vital for handicaps just as the real world trainers and owners want to get there horses as well handicapped as possible before trying for the win
    All horses, no matter what age,start racing in a maiden race,unless deemed to be top class by either its breeding or training performance.After its maiden race it will be assessed and given a rating.This rating will determine the lowest class of race it can enter ie if say the horse wins a maiden and is allocated a rating of say 70 it could enter a 0-70 handicap but would carry top weight
    yep
  19. Post 19 by Brisflyers

    Permalink, post#19
    identify challies no no no the games been dumbed down enough as it is yall be wanting a seasons racing plan for a horse sent to inbox by master trainer for $5 next loooool
  20. Post 20 by Lucky 15

    Permalink, post#20

    Brisflyers wrote view post

    identify challies no no no the games been dumbed down enough as it is yall be wanting a seasons racing plan for a horse sent to inbox by master trainer for $5 next loooool
    Yes please that would be great I only need to login once a season then lol

Log in to join the conversation.